Random Pizza Toppings

What Sauce Goes With White Pizza? 5 Options

6 min read. Published .

The sauce under a white pizza seasons the base, sets how wet the middle gets and supplies the fat, all from under the cheese. Five sauces are worth building on: olive oil with garlic, a drained ricotta spread, a bechamel, a reduced garlic and parmesan cream, and whipped cream cheese. Which one you want comes down to what is going on top, how wet those toppings are, and how hot your oven runs. Pick badly and you get a pale, wet middle with a rim of oil around the crust.

None of these behave like tomato. Tomato sauce is mostly water with acid and sugar in it, and it sits on the dough and boils off while the crust sets. A fat-based sauce does the opposite. It insulates the dough, it spreads as it warms, and it will happily run to the edge of the pizza if you put too much on.

Olive oil and garlic

The simplest white base is olive oil with garlic in it, and it is the one most home cooks get slightly wrong. Raw sliced garlic scattered on oil scorches on a stone at full heat before the cheese browns. Warm the garlic in the oil first over low heat until it smells sweet, let it cool, then brush the oil over the dough and leave a clean 1 cm (1/2 in) margin at the rim. About 15 ml (1 tablespoon) covers a 30 cm (12 in) round. Pour it on and the oil pools in the middle, fries the dough there, and leaves the rest bare.

An oil base gives you no body at all, so it cannot hold water for you. That matters most for the cheese. Fresh mozzarella, the soft ball packed in liquid, holds several points more water than the low-moisture block (the brackets are set out in mozzarella by moisture level), which is why it weeps across a bare oiled crust. If you want fresh mozzarella on an oil base, tear it, salt it, and let it drain on paper for twenty minutes first.

Oil suits dry, salty, aromatic toppings: prosciutto laid on after the bake, thin potato, rosemary, chilli, anchovy, hard grated cheese. It is a poor choice under mushrooms, spinach, clams or anything else that gives up liquid, because there is nothing there to absorb what they release.

Ricotta and fresh-cheese spreads

Ricotta works as a spread, and treating it as a pourable sauce is the usual failure. Whole-milk ricotta runs roughly 74 percent water, against about 50 percent for whole-milk mozzarella, so close to three-quarters of what you are spooning on is water. Smear that edge to edge and you have laid a wet blanket over raw dough.

Two moves fix it. Drain the ricotta in a fine sieve for an hour and discard what collects underneath, then beat it with salt, black pepper, lemon zest and a spoonful of grated hard cheese so it stiffens and tastes of something. Then dollop it. Spaced spoonfuls leave open dough between them, steam escapes from the gaps, and the crust still browns. A drained, seasoned ricotta with a light brush of oil underneath is the base most spinach and artichoke pizzas should have been built on.

Goat cheese behaves similarly and carries more acid, which helps on a pizza with no tomato in it. Burrata does not belong under the heat at all. Tear it over the finished pizza while the crust is still hot and let it slump.

Bechamel

Bechamel is the only white base with real structure. Cook about 15 g (1 tablespoon) of butter with the same amount of flour for a minute, whisk in about 240 ml (1 cup) of milk, simmer until it coats a spoon, then season it hard with salt, white pepper, nutmeg and cooked garlic. The starch holds the water in the sauce instead of releasing it into the dough, which is why bechamel handles the toppings that defeat oil. Mushrooms, wilted greens, clams and broccolini all give up liquid, and a starch-bound sauce absorbs it instead of drowning in it.

Reduced garlic and parmesan cream

Reduced cream with garlic and grated parmesan does the same job by a different route, thickening through evaporation and fat instead of flour. It tastes richer and it breaks more easily, so keep it below a simmer once the cheese goes in. This is the sauce under most of the classic combinations, from potato, rosemary and pancetta to a garlic cream with clams.

Thickness is the thing to judge. The sauce should mound on the back of a spoon and fall off slowly. Thinner than that and it runs to the rim and burns there. Thicker and it sets into a pasty layer that never melts into the crumb. About 80 ml (a third of a cup) goes on a 30 cm (12 in) pizza, spread with the back of a spoon in a spiral, and stopped short of the edge.

Whipped cheese bases

A whipped base starts from cream cheese, often loosened with sour cream or creme fraiche. A typical cream cheese is about 34 percent fat and 53 percent water, so it is far drier and far fatter than ricotta. It will not run anywhere. It also will not melt into the dough the way bechamel does, and it stays as a distinct layer under the toppings.

That layer is a feature on a pizza built around smoked salmon, dill and red onion, or under heaps of caramelised onion, where a tangy cheese plate under the toppings is the point. Whip it with a splash of milk until it spreads without tearing the dough, and go thin. At the top of a home oven's range it can grease out and form a skin, so this is the base to use when your bake is short and your toppings go on after.

Seasoning a pizza with no tomato in it

Tomato brings acid, sweetness and glutamate, and pulling it out leaves a gap in all three. Salt the base itself rather than salting the top, because a spoonful of unseasoned dairy sitting on dough tastes of nothing. Cooked garlic gives you depth without the burn. Grated hard cheese in the sauce covers the savoury note. Lemon zest, a squeeze of juice after the bake, capers, chilli flakes or a scatter of fresh herbs put back the brightness the tomato was doing, and all of them work better added to the finished pizza than baked into it.

Match the base to the wettest thing going on top. Oil suits dry, cured and aromatic toppings. Drained ricotta works in spoonfuls with open dough between them. Bechamel or reduced cream goes under mushrooms, wilted greens and clams, because a starch- or fat-bound sauce holds the liquid they give up. Whipped cream cheese suits a short bake with the toppings added afterwards.

Keep exploring

More guides

Send feedback

Tell us what went wrong or what you would like to see.

What is it about?

Sent with the address of this page. See the privacy policy.