Hot honey goes with salty, fatty and creamy toppings, because it brings the two things those toppings lack: sugar to set against the salt, and chilli heat that the fat carries across the tongue. Cured pork, sausage, bacon, ricotta and sharp or salty cheeses suit it. Toppings that are already sweet, or delicate enough to be flattened by sugar, fight it.
Cured meats and sausage
Cured pork is the natural partner. Pepperoni cups as it bakes and holds small pools of rendered fat, so a thin line of honey across the top lands in them. Soppressata is saltier and funkier than pepperoni, which gives the sugar more to work against.
Sausage brings the same salt and fat with more chew, and a fennel-seasoned one adds an anise note the honey sits well beside. Raw sausage pinched into small pieces goes on as usual, as long as it is cooked through in the bake, and the honey still goes on afterwards (the piece size is covered in raw sausage on a pizza). Bacon adds smoke to the sweet and the heat.
Creamy and sharp cheeses
Ricotta gives the honey somewhere soft to land. Whole-milk ricotta runs about 74 percent water, so drain it and use it in spoonfuls with open dough between them. Blue cheese and goat cheese bring funk and acid that the sugar rounds off. A salty hard cheese, pecorino or a firm feta, keeps roasted squash or sweet potato from tipping the whole pie into sweetness.
Vegetables
Broccoli rabe (cime di rapa) has a bitter edge the honey softens. Mushrooms take the drizzle well once they have been cooked down hard, because a watery mushroom thins the honey into a slick. Jalapeño or pickled chilli adds acid and a second heat. Caramelised onion works only on a pie with plenty of salt elsewhere, since onion and honey are both sweet.
Toppings that fight it
Pineapple and other sweet toppings give the pie two sugars and nothing to cut them. Fresh tomato, light seafood and herb-led pies lose their flavour under it. A heavily sauced red pie already carries the sweetness of the tomato, and the drizzle flattens it further.
Fresh mozzarella tastes right with hot honey and releases water as it bakes, and that water turns a clean drizzle into a puddle. Tear it and drain it first, or use low-moisture mozzarella as the base and keep the fresh cheese to a few torn pieces, for the reasons set out in mozzarella by moisture level.
The honey itself
Hot honey varies a lot from jar to jar. A mild, fruity one has room for a second heat source such as jalapeño or Calabrian chilli. A properly hot one carries the pizza on its own. Taste it off a spoon before planning the toppings.
Making it at home takes one small pan. Warm honey gently with chilli flakes and a splash of vinegar, keep it below a simmer so it does not scorch, then let it stand off the heat while the chilli steeps. The vinegar keeps it from reading as syrup. Strain it for a clean drizzle or leave the flakes in.
Putting it on
Honey goes on after the bake, because its sugar burns in the oven. Thin lines across the whole pie spread the sweetness, where a pool in the centre adds liquid to the softest part of the base. A warm jar pours in thin lines and a cold one in blobs, so stand the jar in hot water while the pizza bakes. Drizzle after slicing, so the wheel does not drag the honey around.
A low-moisture mozzarella base with pepperoni or soppressata, a few spoonfuls of drained ricotta and some sliced jalapeño, finished with thin lines of honey after slicing, puts salt, fat, cream, acid and heat on one pie with a single sweet element.